The Gazette has new information about the investigation into some 4 million gallons of water that were stolen, allegedly by a Palmer Lake couple Terry Tolbert and Katrina Tolbert. The paper is reporting in 2025 Palmer Lake Utilities officials noticed large amounts of water that were simply missing during the overnight hours. They could not find any leaks, but further testing led them to a water main that was feeding the property of the Tolberts. Neighbors say they were suspicious because while drought conditions had dried up area vegetation and some minor water sources, the Tolberts pond was full and their vegetation was green. Further investigation by the El Paso County Sheriff’s office led to the arrest of the 2, who have been charged with criminal mischief and theft.
